Archive for the ‘Daisy Duke’ Category

Ergun Caner, Rick and Bubba, and Daisy Duke: How LBTS Does Apologetics

April 20, 2010

Ergun Caner was on the nationally broadcast “Rick and Bubba Show.” The name may sound a little backwoods to my urban readers, but Ergun Caner’s own web page makes a big deal about this show (link to discussion). This is touted on that link as being an example of how LU does apologetics: “As you can see at LBTS, we don’t just talk apologetics, we do apologetics.”

You can imagine our disappointment then at listening to the show, particularly the linked five and a half minute segment (the entire show apparently stretched to 90 minutes, this appears to be the first segment of the show) and finding the following comments (link to clip from start of show):

1) “I was raised in – I’m Turkish – 21 generations”

This may be technically true, because he changed his sentence halfway through, but he is giving the false impression he came from Turkey. Instead, he came from Sweden.

2) “Came to America when I was 13 years old.”

As far as we can tell he was 4 years old, or so, when he came to America from Sweden.

3) “My father wasn’t the imam but he was the ‘ulema’ one of the scholars in the mosque.”

Elsewhere in Caner’s discussion of his father, his father takes on various roles in the mosque. As best we can gather from the conflicting evidence, his father occasionally served as a “مؤذن mu’aḏḏin” which is not a kind of scholar, but rather someone who leads the prayers (something like a worship leader).

4) “This was the 70’s, ’78.”

Caner was born in 1966, so Caner wasn’t 13 until 1979. Moreover, Caner came to America around 1970. (UPDATE: I say “around 1970” because all we know for sure is that it was between 1968 when Ergun’s brother Erdem was born and 1970 when Ergun’s brother Emir was born.)

5) “Lost my family, lost everything”

He was disowned by his non-custodial father. It is a sad loss to be disowned by one’s father, but it is not quite the same as being disowned by one’s entire family and losing everything.

6) “That’s the only television I saw – the only American television, the only American television in Turkey, was whatever got approved, and so we got the Dukes of Hazzard … “

a) Ergun didn’t live in Turkey.

b) We’re supposed to believe that Islamic Turkish censors approved the Dukes of Hazzard?

c) The Dukes of Hazzard didn’t start until January 26, 1979

You might think that “Dukes of Hazzard” was just a slip of the tongue. But on another occasion, Ergun Caner made the same claim and further embellished it: “The second television we received was a thing called, ‘The Dukes of Hazzard.’ Man- whew – I know we in church and everything, but I wanted to marry Daisy. I wanted to go to the Boar’s Nest – I wanted to drive a car like this …” (link to clip).

7) “… every two weeks we would get out of Georgia, from TBS, Gordon Solie Georgia Championship Wrestling.”

TBS was launched December 17, 1976, which is also when the show (with TBS as a station) hit satellite. As noted above, Caner came to America with his family from Sweden in 1970. (UPDATE: as noted above, 1970 is the latest date, based on the fact that Emir was born in the U.S.)

Was the remainder of the 90 minutes better than the first five? I hope so. I’m sure Dr. Caner has a lot of good things to say. I’ve heard him say some pretty intelligent things. Nevertheless, may I suggest that this is not what LBTS wants to list as being an example of how LBTS does apologetics.


%d bloggers like this: